The GEO and AEO agencies ChatGPT recommends in New York

As of 15 Nov 2026 · 8 weeks of history · based on 72 ChatGPT answers over the last 5 weeks

ChatGPT's most-recommended agency in New York right now is JH SEO Agency, named in 8 of 72 tracked answers (11% of answers) over the last 5 weeks.

New York has one of the largest concentrations of marketing and SEO agencies in the United States, and many now sell GEO and AEO work: getting clients named in AI answers. These are the agencies ChatGPT itself recommends there, across eight industries.

Note: Many of these agencies offer ChatGPT SEO services as part of wider AEO and GEO work, which usually covers other AI engines too.

Gemini, Claude, ChatGPT SEO agency leaderboard for New York

Ranked by how often ChatGPT names each agency across all industry prompts tracked for New York.

The leaderboard — rolling share of answers, answer count, and average position per agency.
#AgencyShare of answers (5-week avg)AnswersAvg position
1JH SEO Agency▲ 1 POS11.1%8 of 72 answers3.5
2Media Pillars▲ 4 POS11.1%8 of 72 answers3.8
3Progression Agency▲ 1 POS11.1%8 of 72 answers1.4
4PBJ Marketing▼ 1 POS11.1%8 of 72 answers2.8
5Amsive▲ 2 POS9.7%7 of 72 answers1.9
6iPullRank▼ 5 POS9.7%7 of 72 answers2.9
7InterCore▲ 1 POS8.3%6 of 72 answers1.5
8FlyDragon▲ 3 POS6.9%5 of 72 answers2.9
9NTL of NYC6.9%5 of 72 answers1.2
10Sosemo6.9%5 of 72 answers2.2
11Sure Oak▼ 6 POS6.9%5 of 72 answers4.0
12Fuel Online▲ 14 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers2.8
13Sirianni Digital▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers2.3
14Lodging Interactive▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers2.0
15Aleph Agency▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers2.3
16MedVisibility▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers3.3
17NYC Healthcare Marketing▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers2.3
18ElephantNY Studio▼ 1 POS5.6%4 of 72 answers1.5
19Thrive Internet Marketing Agency▲ 27 POS4.2%3 of 72 answers3.3
20NYFTY Labs▲ 14 POS4.2%3 of 72 answers4.0

Ranked by share of answers — how often ChatGPT names each agency over the last 5 weeks, across all 8 industries. Average position is a separate measure: where the agency lands within the answers that do name it. ChatGPT's picks sometimes include firms based outside New York and software tools; we list what it recommended, without vetting.

Share-of-answers trend

Weekly · share of answers per agency

0%13%25%PBJ MARKETINGPROGRESSION AGENCYNTL OF NYCSOSEMOAMSIVE2026-09-212026-11-02
Tracked weekly on ChatGPT · hover a week for detail

Best Industry-Wise New York AI SEO and AEO agencies

All 8 industries tracked for New York, one prompt each.

JH SEO Agency leads in New York overall — but not in every industry:

The actual answers we got for buyer prompts when recording ChatGPT agency recommendations in New York

One complete, unedited ChatGPT answer per prompt — the receipts behind the numbers above.

“My competitors show up when people ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude for recommendations in New York and I don't. Which agencies in New York can fix that?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

The service you’re looking for is usually called AI search visibility, GEO (generative engine optimization), or AEO (answer engine optimization). I’d shortlist these New York-area agencies, depending on what kind of help you need:

  • Amsive — A strong first call for an established company that needs technical SEO and content work alongside AI visibility. Its AEO offering covers audits, crawlability, structured data, and content strategy for AI search. amsive.com
  • 5W — Worth considering if your competitors are being recommended because of press, reviews, and other third-party coverage. 5W combines GEO with PR and says it tracks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and other platforms. Its site lists programs starting at $20,000/month, so it may be geared toward larger budgets. 5wpr.com
  • Animalz — A possible fit if the gap is mainly content and thought leadership, especially for B2B or SaaS. Its AEO service includes an AI-visibility audit and a strategy for ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews. animalz.co
  • United Of Web — A New York option explicitly offering GEO on top of technical SEO, with monthly citation measurement. Ask for examples and references in your specific industry before deciding. unitedofweb.com

How I’d choose: ask each agency to run the same buyer questions—such as “best [your service] in New York”—across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude, then show which competitors appear and which sources those answers rely on. Get a written baseline, a competitor comparison, a concrete work plan, and reporting tied to qualified leads—not just a proprietary “AI visibility score.”

Be wary of anyone promising a guaranteed spot in ChatGPT or a fixed ranking: AI answers vary, and no agency controls them. If you tell me your industry, company size, and whether you’re targeting NYC locally or customers statewide, I can narrow this to the best-fit options.

“Which AEO agencies in New York work with financial advisors and insurance firms?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

Assuming you mean AEO = answer engine optimization—helping a firm appear in answers from tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google’s AI results—these New York options look relevant:

AgencyNew York connectionRelevant fit
Progression AgencyNew York City-basedThe clearest direct match for both insurers and wealth managers: it explicitly offers AEO for financial services, including insurers and wealth firms, with attention to regulated content and disclosures. progressionagency.com
Eleven Digital GroupNYC-headquarteredOffers SEO/GEO and AI marketing; names RIAs, financial advisors, planners, and wealth-management firms among its clients. Its public site doesn’t specifically list insurance firms, so ask about that experience. elevendigitalgroup.com
GregoryHas a New York presenceFinancial-services PR and GEO/AI search; its stated client sectors include RIAs, insurers, and other financial firms. It may suit firms where media coverage and reputation are important parts of the AEO strategy. gregoryagency.com
PerceptureNew York agencyOffers GEO/AEO-style search work for insurance agencies, brokers, and carriers. The evidence I found is stronger for insurance than for financial-advisor specialization. aeolabs.ai
TerakeetBased in Syracuse, NYA larger-scale option for brands focused on reputation and AI visibility; it has published an insurance case study, but the insurer is unnamed, and the evidence is not specifically about financial advisors. aeolabs.ai

Best initial shortlist: Progression for a provider explicitly addressing both sectors; Eleven Digital Group for advisor/wealth firms; Gregory for financial-services firms seeking an AEO-plus-PR approach; and Percepture for insurance-focused work.

Before hiring, ask for relevant client examples, which AI platforms and prompts they track, how they handle compliance review, and whether results mean actual citations or just increased traditional search traffic. Public proof in this niche is limited, so request specifics rather than relying on broad claims. aeolabs.ai

“Which AI SEO agencies in New York, United States specialize in real estate agents and brokerages?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

The clearest matches I found are:

AgencyWhy it may fitNew York connection
AdvantEdge Marketing SolutionsExplicitly markets SEO and AI-search optimization to Realtors, brokerages, and other luxury real-estate professionals. Its New York page also lists website design, content marketing, and lead generation. advantedgemarketingsolutions.comHas a New York service page; confirm whether it is based in NYC or simply serves the area.
PursuitNew York real-estate marketing agency that says it offers AI-search optimization alongside real-estate branding and digital marketing. Its stated clients are mainly developers, property owners, and managers, so ask whether it takes on agent- or brokerage-level SEO engagements. agencyinpursuit.comLists a New York, NY address.
SmartSitesOffers real-estate marketing, SEO, and “Search + AI SEO” for real-estate professionals, and features a NYC real-estate team as a client. smartsites.comServes New York clients; verify its current office location and how much of its AI-search work is specific to real estate.

Specialist alternative, not New York–based: FlyDragon focuses specifically on AI search optimization (AEO/GEO) for agents, teams, and brokerages, and reports work in New York markets. It appears to serve clients across the U.S. rather than operate as a New York agency. goflydragon.com

Bottom line: AdvantEdge and SmartSites look like the most direct starting points for an agent or brokerage seeking both real-estate marketing and AI-search services; Pursuit may be a better fit for property- or development-focused marketing. Before hiring, ask for examples of agent or brokerage results in your target NYC neighborhoods, what “AI SEO” includes (such as Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity visibility), and how they measure leads or citations—not just rankings.

“Which generative engine optimization agencies in New York work with hotels and restaurants?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

Here are the clearest matches I found. “New York” can mean NYC-based or serving New York clients, so I’ve noted the distinction—and whether the agency’s hospitality focus is hotels, restaurants, or both.

AgencyNew York connectionHospitality fit
HarvestLists a New York officeWorks with both hotels and restaurants and offers AI search optimization alongside SEO and other hospitality marketing services. harvestagency.ai
Mojo DojoOffers a New York-focused serviceExplicitly covers hospitality, dining, and tourism, including keeping restaurants’ and hotels’ details consistent across sources AI tools may use. mojodojo.io
ElephantNY StudioPresents itself as a New York studioThe most restaurant-specific option I found: it focuses on NYC restaurant AI visibility and describes audits and fixes involving menus, listings, and structured data. elephantny.com
HAICHas a New York service page and says it serves New York businessesOffers GEO and AI citation monitoring, and lists hotels/hospitality and restaurants/food & beverage among its New York industries. thehaic.com
O’Rourke HospitalityServes hospitality clients, including a hotel on Long Island; confirm its local-office situationHospitality-first GEO aimed at properties and reservations. The evidence I found is strongest for hotels; ask whether they handle standalone restaurants. orourkehospitality.com
Lodging InteractiveBased in Parsippany, New Jersey—not NYC, but nearby and serving North AmericaA strong hotel-focused GEO option; its broader hospitality services also include restaurants. lodginginteractive.com

Quick shortlist: For a restaurant, start with ElephantNY, Harvest, or Mojo Dojo. For a hotel, consider O’Rourke or Lodging Interactive, and compare them with Harvest or Mojo Dojo if having a New York-area presence matters.

GEO is a relatively new service category, and agency claims aren’t the same as independently verified results. Before hiring, ask for dated examples of AI visibility work for similar properties, what they measure, and how they’ll connect it to bookings or covers.

“Which GEO agencies in New York are best for medical clinics and med spas?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

For New York medical clinics and med spas, I’d shortlist these based on healthcare specialization and whether they explicitly offer GEO/AI-search work—not on an independently verified ranking of results:

AgencyBest fitWhy consider them
MedVisibilityMedical practices wanting a local, multi-channel planHealthcare-only focus; its New York offering includes local SEO, websites, Google/Meta ads, reputation work, and GEO. It specifically discusses New York neighborhood-level competition and compliance considerations. medvisibility.com
NYC Healthcare MarketingClinics wanting healthcare-focused GEO plus broader marketingExplicit GEO services, including practice/entity information, structured data, healthcare content, and AI-visibility tracking; also offers SEO and other practice-growth services. Treat its published performance claims as agency claims and ask for references and supporting data. nychealthcare.marketing
NYFTY LabsMed spas seeking an end-to-end growth partnerIts med-spa offering covers local SEO, paid search/social, reviews, conversion tracking, and GEO. Ask for examples from actual med-spa clients and clarify which services are handled in-house. nyftylabs.com
JH SEO AgencyAesthetic practices prioritizing search visibilityA recent agency roundup describes dedicated GEO pages for med spas, plastic surgeons, and healthcare. I’d verify its New York presence, team, and relevant client results directly before shortlisting it seriously. webtonic.io

My practical take: Start with MedVisibility for a medical clinic and NYFTY Labs for a med spa; compare NYC Healthcare Marketing if GEO is a major priority. These are starting points, not endorsements—GEO is still an evolving service category, and agency promises of guaranteed AI mentions should be a red flag.

Before signing, ask each agency for:

  • Named, relevant client references and before/after lead or booking data.
  • A sample audit showing how it measures AI visibility—and how that ties to calls or bookings.
  • Who writes and clinically reviews treatment content.
  • What’s included in the fee, who owns the website/content, and whether there’s a long-term contract.
  • How it handles patient privacy, advertising claims, and any required medical review.

If you share your borough/city, clinic specialty, and whether you need ads and social media too, I can narrow the shortlist further.

“Which law firm marketing agencies in New York offer LLM SEO to get firms cited by ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

Several agencies explicitly market AI-search optimization for law firms serving New York. The services may be called GEO (generative engine optimization), AEO (answer engine optimization), or LLM SEO.

AgencyWhat its public offering says
InterCore TechnologiesLegal-marketing specialist with New York offices; promotes GEO/AEO for law firms and names ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude among the AI tools it targets. intercore.net
Gotham SEOFocuses on small and solo NYC firms; describes AI-search optimization alongside local and traditional SEO. gothamseo.com
PioneerlyOffers New York law-firm marketing and says its AEO/GEO work aims to help firms be recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. pioneerly.com
Atty.digitalLaw-firm-only marketing agency with a New York presence; promotes GEO for visibility in ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. atty.digital
360 LawFirmMarkets legal marketing in New York and says its AI-search service targets visibility in ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI results. 360lawfirmmarketer.com
9SailLegal-focused digital marketing agency; includes GEO in its law-firm visibility services. It also publishes an annual digital-visibility analysis of Am Law 200 firms. 9sail.com

Worth checking, though not necessarily New York-based: LaFleur Legal Marketing describes GEO as part of law-firm SEO and names ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude; Network Labs says it specializes in personal-injury firms and tracks visibility across major LLMs, including those three. lafleurlegalmarketing.com

One caution: no agency can guarantee that ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude will cite or recommend a particular firm. Treat “get cited” as a goal, not a promised placement. Ask for before-and-after examples for relevant practice-area and New York prompts, which engines they test, how often they retest, and whether they report actual citations/recommendations—not just AI-readiness scores. InterCore, Gotham SEO, and Pioneerly look like the clearest starting points if you specifically want a New York-focused provider.

“Who are the best agencies in New York for getting plumbing and HVAC companies recommended by ChatGPT?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

There isn’t a credible, independent ranking of agencies that can reliably get plumbers or HVAC companies recommended by ChatGPT—and no agency can guarantee a recommendation. Based on New York location, trade fit, and specific AI-search services, I’d start with:

  1. Capinity — Wantagh, NY Best fit if you want an agency focused specifically on contractors. It says it works exclusively with home-service businesses, including plumbing and HVAC, and combines local SEO and AI-search work with lead capture and follow-up tools. Ask for examples of plumbing or HVAC clients and proof of ChatGPT visibility gains; its public site describes the services but doesn’t show trade-specific results. capinity.com
  1. Media Pillars — Granville, NY A promising option for trades serving Upstate New York, the Catskills, or nearby areas. Its offering is unusually concrete: monthly checks of ChatGPT and other AI answers, Google Business Profile work, service-area pages, reviews, listings, and reporting. Its site lists a $497 audit, but I’d still ask for relevant contractor case studies before hiring. mediapillars.com
  1. Thrive Internet Marketing Agency — Manhattan A larger, full-service option if you also need conventional SEO, local search, reviews, and digital PR. It explicitly offers AI-search services, but the examples on its NYC page are from other industries—not plumbing or HVAC—so verify trade experience and who would actually manage your account. thriveagency.com
  1. United Of Web — Manhattan Worth considering if you want a specialist GEO engagement with defined AI-visibility tracking. It publishes a starting price of $7,499/month for its GEO plan and reports local-service results for a moving company, but the evidence I found isn’t plumbing- or HVAC-specific. unitedofweb.com

My first calls: Capinity for trade specialization; Media Pillars for a more focused local-search and AI-visibility program. For a larger budget and broader marketing needs, also talk to Thrive.

Before signing, ask each agency to:

  • Show verifiable plumbing/HVAC results in your actual service area.
  • Track a fixed set of realistic prompts—such as “best plumber in [town]”—and report which businesses are named and cited.
  • Explain how it will improve your Google Business Profile, reviews, service-area pages, and consistent business listings.
  • Report on calls and booked jobs, not just AI mentions or impressions.
  • Put scope, reporting, and cancellation terms in writing—and avoid anyone promising guaranteed ChatGPT rankings.
“Who are the top agencies in New York that help dental practices rank in AI search?”ChatGPT · 13 Nov 2026

“AI search” usually means improving a practice’s chances of being mentioned in ChatGPT, Google’s AI features, Gemini, or Perplexity—not guaranteeing a particular ranking. For New York, these are good agencies to shortlist:

  • Digital Limelight Media — Has a published case study for Brooklyn’s Grand Street Dental, reporting strong traditional search results after four months. It serves New York, though its listed office is in Michigan. f.hubspotusercontent10.net
  • Doctor Rank — The clearest local, dental-only option in one current New York AEO/GEO directory; it lists a New York office and says it tracks AI visibility. The directory notes it found no public case study. eliteaeo.ai
  • Fuel Online — Serves New York and offers AEO, AI-visibility reporting, and dental case studies; the directory lists a $5,000+ starting price. eliteaeo.ai
  • Thrive Internet Marketing Agency — A larger, full-service option that serves New York, works with dental clients, and offers AI-search services and visibility reporting. eliteaeo.ai
  • Aleph Agency — Has a Forest Hills dental case study that claims Google Maps placement and visibility in AI-generated summaries. Treat those as agency-reported results and ask for the underlying measurement. alephagency.com

My practical take: Start by talking with Doctor Rank if having a New York-based dental specialist matters most; compare it with Digital Limelight Media or Fuel Online if you want published dental evidence and a more explicit AI-visibility offering. These are a shortlist, not a definitive ranking—the available directory reports only one of its seven providers has a New York office, and only three publish dental case studies. eliteaeo.ai

Before signing, ask each agency to show a sample report with the exact patient prompts and AI platforms tracked, how often they check them, and whether your practice was actually named or cited. Also ask for a dental client reference and how they connect AI visibility to calls or booked appointments.

Sources behind the Gemini, Claude, ChatGPT SEO agency recommendations in New York

The domains ChatGPT cites most across this city's answers.
DomainCitationsShare of top sources
agencies.semrush.com138%
5wpr.com96%
progressionagency.com96%
alephagency.com85%
intercore.net85%
mediapillars.com85%
pbjmarketing.com85%
elephantny.com74%
goflydragon.com74%
aeooptimization.ai64%

The pages ChatGPT cites most when recommending AI search agencies in New York

How to get cited by ChatGPT and other AI engines in New York

  1. Build one page per industry you serve: Buyers usually ask AI engines about their own industry, so an agency with a dedicated page for each industry it serves is generally easier to match to those prompts than one with a single generic services page. Specialists with a dedicated page often win their industry prompt outright. In New York, Progression Agency leads finance with 9 of 9 answers.
  2. Name the service and the city in the page title: The page title is a strong signal of what a page covers, so a title that states both the service and the city, such as AEO and GEO services in New York, is typically easier for AI engines to match to local buyer prompts. In New York, the most cited page is “AEO for Financial Services | AI Search & ChatGPT Visibility”, with 9 citations.
  3. Publish specifics AI engines can quote: Clear prices, named clients and a defined scope of work are the kind of details that tend to end up in answers.
  4. Back your claims with outside proof: Named client results, reviews and mentions on other sites usually carry more weight than claims on your own site.
  5. Name the AI platforms you cover: When a prompt asks about specific engines, agencies whose pages name those engines tend to be the closer match.
  6. Let AI crawlers reach your content: Check that robots.txt does not block the crawlers used by ChatGPT and other AI engines, and keep key text readable without clicks or scripts. The free AI Crawler Accessibility Checker shows whether your site is reachable.

How to choose a Gemini, Claude, ChatGPT SEO agency in New York

Five checks that usually help before you sign with an agency.

  1. Decide how wide the work should be. If your buyers mostly ask ChatGPT, ChatGPT SEO services may cover what you need. If they also use Gemini, Perplexity or Google AI Overviews, ask for AEO or GEO work across those engines.
  2. Agree on the scope of work. Ask what will change on your site, listings, reviews and third party mentions, so you know what you are paying for.
  3. Check the quality of customer support. Ask who you will work with day to day, how quickly they usually respond, and how often they report progress.
  4. Look at ratings and reviews from other clients. Reviews on Google and agency directories typically give a more balanced picture than case studies on the agency's own site.
  5. Ask for clear pricing and a written quotation. A quote that lists what is included, how long the work runs and what costs extra makes it easier to compare agencies fairly.

FAQ

Which agencies in New York can get my business recommended by ChatGPT?
When buyers generally ask ChatGPT which agencies can get them featured in AI answers in New York, the recommendations include Nu Interactive Media, iPullRank and Amsive, though the best fit depends on your industry, so check the entire industry table thoroughly, too. Also, remember that no agency can fully guarantee a ChatGPT recommendation, since AI answers vary by question and over time.
What do ChatGPT SEO services in New York usually include?
Typically an audit of how ChatGPT answers the questions your customers ask, fixes to your site and business listings, content that ChatGPT can cite, and regular reports on which answers mention you.
Is ChatGPT SEO the same as AEO or GEO?
Not quite. ChatGPT SEO typically means work aimed at getting recommended by ChatGPT specifically. AEO focuses on making content easy for answer engines to use as a direct answer, and GEO on getting cited in generated AI responses, so both usually cover several engines such as Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews.
Can an agency fix incorrect information AI tools show about my company?
Usually, yes. Agencies typically start by finding where the wrong details come from, then correct them on your site, business listings and the third party pages AI tools tend to draw on. Changes can take a while to show, since answers update as those sources are crawled again.
Can an agency guarantee that ChatGPT will recommend my business?
No. AI answers vary by question, wording and over time, so a credible agency usually commits to the work and the reporting, not to a fixed placement.

See which prompts get your brand mentioned in AI answers.